Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
Cash Back vs Travel Rewards: Which Credit Card is Best for You?
December 12, 2024
.webp)
If you’re trying to choose a new rewards credit card, one of the biggest questions is: cash back or travel rewards? Both types of cards can be very rewarding, but they shine in different ways. Cash-back cards offer straightforward savings – a percentage of your spending returned to you – while travel reward cards earn points or miles that can be redeemed for flights, hotels, and other travel perks. The best choice ultimately depends on your spending habits and goals. In this guide, we’ll break down cash back vs. travel rewards in simple terms, compare their pros and cons, and help you figure out which type of credit card is best for you. By the end, you should have a clear idea whether you’d benefit more from easy cash rebates or from free trips and upgrades – or even a combination of both. Let’s dive in!
Understanding Cash Back Credit Cards
Cash-back credit cards reward you by giving back a percentage of what you spend. For example, a card might offer 2% cash back on all purchases, or different rates like 3% on groceries and 1% on everything else. The rewards usually come in the form of statement credits, bank deposits, or checks – basically, cash (hence the name). Here are key features of cash-back cards and why people love them:
- Simplicity: Cash back is easy to understand. If a card gives 2% back, that’s $2 for every $100 spent. There’s no need to learn about points or convert them to dollar values. This makes it very low-maintenance – you always know what your rewards are worth (a dollar is a dollar).
- Flexibility of Use: Cash is universally useful. You can use your cash-back rewards to pay off your credit card bill, deposit into your savings, or spend on anything. There are no restrictions like blackout dates or specific airlines.
- Typically No Annual Fee: Many cash-back cards have no annual fee, so you can earn rewards without a yearly cost eating into your earnings. This is great for beginners or those who want a simple rewards card.
Downsides of Cash Back: While cash back is straightforward, it might not always be the most valuable rewards option for big travelers. Cash-back rates (usually 1-5% on spending) are modest. In contrast, travel points from certain cards can sometimes exceed those values when redeemed strategically (for example, using points for first-class flights can net more than 2¢ per point in value, effectively 10%+ return on spending in some cases). Also, cash back doesn’t come with travel-specific perks – no free checked bags, lounge access, or hotel upgrades, which travel cards often include.
Who should choose Cash Back? If you prefer simplicity, don’t travel often, or want rewards you can use for any expense (not just travel), a cash-back card is very appealing. It’s essentially a rebate on everything you buy. Those who just want a straightforward benefit from their credit card – like help with everyday bills or a way to save a little extra – will find cash back cards attractive.
Understanding Travel Rewards Credit Cards
Travel rewards cards earn points or miles instead of cash. These rewards are typically tied to either a specific brand (like an airline or hotel) or a general travel program. For instance, you might have a card that earns airline miles with Delta, or a bank’s card that earns flexible points you can use for various airlines or hotels.
Key features of travel rewards cards include:
Valuable Redemptions:
Travel points and miles can sometimes be worth more than equivalent cash back. For example, 50,000 points might get you a plane ticket that would cost $600 in cash – that’s a higher value per point than 1% or 2% cash back would give on the same spending. If you know how to use miles for expensive flights or hotel stays, the return on spending can be excellent.
Travel Perks:
Many travel credit cards come packed with additional benefits. These can include things like free checked bags on flights, priority boarding, airport lounge access, annual travel credits (rebates for travel purchases), travel insurance coverage, and hotel room upgrades or late checkout. These perks can significantly enhance your travel experience and save money (for example, not paying bag fees or getting free airport meals in a lounge).
Sign-Up Bonuses:
Travel cards often have large welcome bonuses (e.g. “Earn 60,000 points after spending $4,000 in 3 months”). These bonuses can be enough for a free flight or several hotel nights, jump-starting your travel rewards. Cash-back cards also have bonuses, but travel card bonuses tend to be higher in value (albeit with higher spending requirements).
Downsides of Travel Rewards: With the added value comes a bit more complexity. Points and miles have variables: their value can fluctuate depending on how you use them. Redeeming rewards for travel means you have to plan trips and navigate booking through reward programs or portals. Some travel cards are tied to specific airlines or hotels, which limits your redemption options if you don’t frequently use those brands. Additionally, many travel cards charge annual fees (sometimes $95, or premium cards can be $500+ annually) to support all those perks – which means you need to use the card’s benefits enough to justify that fee each year.
Travel rewards can also be less immediate – you accumulate points and then have to actively redeem them for a trip, whereas cash back just appears as money you can use anytime. If you’re not a planner or don’t want to keep track of reward program rules, this could be a hassle. However, for those who do travel frequently or are willing to learn the ropes, the payoff can be well worth it (free vacations!).
Who should choose Travel Rewards? If you love to travel (or aspire to travel more) and like the idea of getting flights, hotel stays, or upgrades for free, a travel rewards card is ideal. These cards are great for people who don’t mind a bit of extra work to squeeze out more value. For instance, if you take at least a couple of trips a year – whether for work or leisure – a travel card’s perks (like avoiding baggage fees or airport lounge waits) and the ability to book trips with points will likely outweigh the costs. Also, if you enjoy travel hacking or maximizing every dollar, travel cards provide a fun challenge to get the most out of your spending.
Comparing the Pros and Cons
Let’s put them side by side. Here’s a quick comparison of cash-back vs travel rewards credit cards in the areas that matter most:
1. Rewards Value:
- Cash Back: Fixed value (e.g., 1% = $0.01 per $1 spent). No surprises, but also rarely exceeds ~2% except in bonus categories.
- Travel Rewards: Variable value. Points can be worth less or more depending on redemption. You might get outsized value (like 4-5% equivalent) if redeemed strategically for expensive travel, but it requires effort.
2. Ease of Use:
- Cash Back: Extremely easy. Automatic rewards, usually just apply to your statement or bank account. No need to plan how to use them.
- Travel Rewards: More involved. Requires finding award flights or hotel nights, transferring points, dealing with loyalty programs. There can be a learning curve.
3. Flexibility:
- Cash Back: Can be used for anything. It’s cash – pay bills, buy groceries, invest it, you name it.
- Travel Rewards: Best used for travel expenses. Some programs let you cash out points, but often at a lower value (which is not ideal). If your plans change and you can’t travel, your points might sit unused (though some programs allow other options like gift cards or merchandise, usually at a poor rate).
4. Perks and Benefits:
- Cash Back: Typically minimal perks. Some cash-back cards have nice extras (like extended warranty or purchase protection), but generally not travel-specific perks.
- Travel Rewards: Comes with big perks especially on cards with annual fees. Examples: free TSA PreCheck/Global Entry credits, travel insurance, elite status in hotel programs, companion airline tickets, etc. These can significantly enhance your travels.
5. Cost (Annual Fees):
- Cash Back: Many no-annual-fee options. Easy to keep long-term at no cost.
- Travel Rewards: Many have annual fees. Some mid-tier travel cards have ~$95 fees, while premium ones (Chase Sapphire Reserve, Amex Platinum, etc.) have $250-$700 fees. These fees can be worth it if you utilize benefits, but they are a consideration.
6. Earning Rates:
- Cash Back: Often have flat or category-based rates (e.g., 1.5% on everything, or 5% on rotating categories up to a limit). Rarely more complicated than that.
- Travel Rewards: Can have bonus categories too (e.g., 3x points on travel and dining). Sometimes better for travel-related spend. Also, some travel cards earn transferable points (like Chase Ultimate Rewards, Amex Membership Rewards) which add flexibility in how you redeem.
In summary, cash-back cards win on simplicity and flexibility for any expense, while travel cards win on total potential value and travel-related extras.
Making Your Decision: Which to Choose?
Ask yourself a few key questions to decide between cash back and travel rewards:
- Do you travel enough? If you travel frequently (or plan to), a travel rewards card can quickly pay off in free flights and perks. If you rarely travel or prefer road trips and local vacations, a cash-back card might be more practical so your rewards can go toward any expense.
- Do you enjoy planning and optimizing? Travel rewards can require management – keeping track of point balances, learning the best ways to redeem, etc. Some people enjoy this hobby (the “points and miles” enthusiasts), and they get great value. Others might find it a chore. If you want no-fuss rewards, go for cash back. If you don’t mind a bit of effort for a bigger payoff, travel cards are for you.
- What are your financial goals right now? If you could use extra cash in hand – say to pay down debt or boost savings – cash back is immediately helpful. On the other hand, if your budget for travel is limited but you dream of a vacation, a travel card could essentially fund your trip through points. Think about whether free travel or extra cash is more appealing in the next year or two.
It’s Not Always Either/Or: Keep in mind, you can have both types of cards. Many people start with a good cash-back card and later add a travel card (or vice versa). There’s even a strategy in holding multiple cards: use a travel card for travel and dining purchases (to earn high points in those categories and get perks), and use a cash-back card for everyday categories or wherever you want simplicity. This way, you maximize rewards across the board. If you choose to do this, just be sure to manage them responsibly (paying on time, keeping track of multiple bills).
One handy way to juggle multiple cards is to use technology to your advantage. For instance, Kudos (a smart browser extension) can help by automatically suggesting which of your cards to use at checkout for the best reward. If you carry both a cash-back card and a travel card, Kudos will remind you which one gives more value for that particular purchase, ensuring you’re always optimizing without needing to remember each card’s perks yourself. This means you can enjoy the benefits of both cash and travel rewards seamlessly.
Example Scenarios
Sometimes it helps to see real-life scenarios. Here are two quick examples illustrating which card type works best:
- Scenario 1: The Casual Traveler – Sarah mostly stays around town and takes one vacation a year to visit family. She spends a lot on groceries and utilities. A cash-back card that gives 2% on all purchases puts money back in her pocket every month, which she can use to offset her airfare when she buys tickets once a year. She doesn’t want to worry about blackout dates or point conversions. For Sarah, cash back is king because of its everyday usefulness.
- Scenario 2: The Explorer – John travels for work and leisure frequently. He flies at least 4-5 times a year and stays in hotels. He gets a travel rewards card with a $95 annual fee that gives 3x points on travel and dining. In a year, he earns tens of thousands of points. Using those points, he books a vacation flight in business class that would have cost $1,200 – far exceeding what he might have earned in pure cash back. He also enjoys free checked bags and airport lounge access thanks to his card. For John, the travel card clearly provides more overall value and enhances his travel experience.
If you identify more with Sarah, a cash-back card (or two) is a great fit. If you’re more like John, leaning into travel rewards will be more beneficial.
Combining Cash Back and Travel Cards
It’s worth noting that many experts recommend eventually having a combo of cards to cover different needs. You might start with one type and later add the other as your lifestyle or comfort with rewards grows. For example, you could use a no-fee cash-back card for everyday errand spending, and a travel card for your flight, hotel, and dining expenses. This way, you earn some cash for flexibility while also racking up points for your trips.
When combining, try to choose cards that complement each other. Maybe one has rotating 5% categories (to maximize grocery or gas rewards part of the year) and another has 3x on travel (to maximize vacation spending). With a smart strategy, you won’t have to leave any rewards on the table.
Again, tools like Kudos can be invaluable here – it will notify you which card in your wallet yields the highest reward or best benefit for each purchase you’re making online. That means if your travel card would give you 3x points on a flight booking, but your cash-back card is only 1% for that purchase, Kudos will prompt you to use the travel card. Conversely, if you’re buying something where your cash-back card is supreme, you won’t accidentally use the travel card. This kind of assistance makes juggling multiple cards much easier and ensures you’re truly maximizing rewards across the cash vs travel spectrum.
Conclusion
So, cash back or travel rewards? The answer comes down to your personal preferences and lifestyle. If you crave simplicity and liquidity, a cash-back credit card is likely the best for you. If you’re all about traveling or want to unlock luxury experiences and bigger value, a travel rewards credit card is the way to go. There’s no one-size-fits-all – some people even carry one of each to cover all bases.
When choosing, consider trying a cash-back card first if you’re new to rewards, since it’s straightforward. As you get comfortable, you can venture into travel rewards for those aspirational perks. Or, if you have a specific trip in mind, starting with a travel card and earning a big signup bonus could jump-start your journey.
Finally, remember that whichever route you choose, responsible credit card use is key. Always pay your bills in full each month to avoid interest (interest charges can wipe out any rewards, cash or points!). And keep an eye on annual fees to ensure you’re getting value from the card. With that foundation, you can’t go too far wrong.
Whether you end up sipping a latte bought with cash-back dollars or sipping a cocktail in a lounge courtesy of your travel card, you’ll be enjoying the fruits of smart credit card choice. Happy rewarding!
FAQs
Are travel rewards credit cards worth it if I don’t travel a lot?
If you only travel once in a long while, a travel rewards card might not be worth it, especially if it has an annual fee. Infrequent travelers may struggle to earn enough points or use all the perks. In that case, a good cash-back card could provide more tangible benefits. However, there are some no-annual-fee travel cards out there – those could still be worth considering for occasional travelers since they let you accumulate miles over time without a yearly cost. You could then use the points for that rare trip when it happens. Evaluate how often you realistically will use the card’s rewards. If it’s just one flight every year or two, lean towards cash back or a no-fee travel card.
Can I convert cash back into travel rewards or vice versa?
Not directly in most cases. Cash-back rewards typically can’t be turned into airline miles or hotel points. Similarly, points from a travel card can’t usually be converted to pure cash at full value. That said, some programs blur the lines: for example, certain bank “travel” points (like Capital One Miles or Chase Ultimate Rewards) can be used as cash credits for travel purchases or even transferred to airline partners. And some cash-back cards let you use cash for travel (by booking travel through their portal). But generally, if you want flexibility to do both, consider a flexible points card – these are travel-oriented cards where points can be redeemed for travel or cashed out (Chase Sapphire Preferred, for instance, lets you use points for travel through Chase or transfer to airlines, or even cash them out at a lower rate). It’s not exactly converting, but it gives you options.
Is having both a cash-back and travel credit card a good idea?
Yes, it can be. Many people maintain a small portfolio of cards to maximize rewards. A cash-back card can handle everyday non-travel purchases (and serve as a backup for places that might not award travel bonus points), while a travel card can be used when you want to earn or redeem for trips. By having both, you can enjoy easy cash on some spending and high-value points on others. Just be mindful of managing multiple accounts responsibly – keep track of payment due dates and make sure the combined credit limits don’t tempt you to overspend. When used wisely, having multiple cards allows you to leverage the strengths of each. And as mentioned, you can use tools like Kudos to remind you which card to use when – effectively getting the best of both worlds without the guesswork.
Supercharge Your Credit Cards
Experience smarter spending with Kudos and unlock more from your credit cards. Earn $20.00 when you sign up for Kudos with "GET20" and make an eligible Kudos Boost purchase.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
.webp)
.webp)
