Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
Geico vs Progressive – Car Insurance Comparison for 2025
February 6, 2025
Geico and Progressive are two of the most popular car insurance companies in the United States. If you’re shopping for auto insurance, there’s a good chance these two are at the top of your list – and you might be wondering, Geico vs. Progressive: which is better? Both insurers are known for competitive rates and extensive advertising, but how do they actually compare on price, discounts, coverage and customer service? In this 2025 comparison, we’ll break down the key differences (and similarities) between Geico and Progressive. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which company might be the best fit for your needs. Remember, the “better” insurer can vary depending on what you value most – price, service, specific features – so we’ll cover all those angles.
Price Comparison – Who Offers Cheaper Insurance?
For many people, the decision comes down to cost. Both Geico and Progressive market themselves as saving customers money. Here’s how they stack up on price:
Overall Average Rates:
Geico generally has the edge in price for a majority of drivers. Various analyses have found that Geico’s average premiums tend to be lower than Progressive’s for similar coverage. In fact, one study found Geico has a cheaper average rate than Progressive in 82% of U.S. states. That’s a strong indicator that Geico often comes out ahead on price.
Example Premiums:
To illustrate, Insurify compared average quotes and noted Geico’s average quote for a basic liability policy was around $55, whereas Progressive’s was about $101 (likely per month). That suggests Geico was roughly half the price in that comparison scenario. While individual quotes will vary, this aligns with the general trend that Geico undercuts Progressive for many driver profiles.
Drivers with Clean Records:
If you have a clean driving history and good credit, Geico is very likely to offer a lower rate than Progressive. Geico’s underwriting favors low-risk drivers with some of the cheapest rates in the market. Progressive’s rates for clean drivers are still competitive (often in the lowest 3 or 4 options), but Geico often beats it by a noticeable margin.
Drivers with Accidents or Violations:
This is where it can flip. Progressive is known to be more forgiving for drivers with a less-than-perfect record. For example, drivers with a recent DUI might actually get a better rate with Progressive than Geico. Progressive tends to surcharge such violations less aggressively. Data backs this: Progressive can have lower premiums for drivers with DUIs or certain accidents. So, if you have tickets or an at-fault accident, Progressive might come out cheaper than Geico, which heavily favors a clean record.
Regional Variations:
Both companies operate in all 50 states, but their pricing competitiveness can vary by state. In some states, Progressive is very close to Geico or even cheaper for certain coverage levels. It’s always best to compare quotes in your specific location. But broadly speaking, Geico has the price advantage for most scenarios, with Progressive being the go-to for some high-risk cases or unique circumstances.
Bottom Line on Price: Geico wins on price for most low-risk drivers with its consistently lower average rates. Progressive isn’t far behind and might beat Geico if you have a violation or need a special coverage that Geico prices high. It’s worth noting that both companies are typically cheaper than many other insurers (like Allstate or Nationwide) for a wide range of drivers, which is why they are so often compared.
Coverage Options and Discounts
Both Geico and Progressive offer all the standard auto insurance coverages you’d expect: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, personal injury protection (in required states), and so on. You won’t be lacking essential coverage with either. The differences lie in the extras and discount programs:
Unique Coverages:
Geico has a notable unique option – Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI) – which acts like an extended warranty for your car, covering major mechanical repairs on newer vehicles. Progressive doesn’t offer an equivalent; if you want MBI, Geico is the choice. Progressive, on the other hand, offers custom parts and equipment coverage for those who have aftermarket upgrades on their car (Geico offers this too, but Progressive emphasizes it for modded car enthusiasts). Both companies offer gap insurance for financed cars, although Progressive’s gap coverage (called “Loan/Lease payoff”) will cover up to 25% above the car’s value, which is a solid benefit.
Accident Forgiveness:
Both insurers have some form of accident forgiveness. Progressive’s comes via its Loyalty Rewards – after a certain time with Progressive, or if you buy it as an add-on, your first accident won’t raise your rate. Geico’s accident forgiveness is earned after five years accident-free (or can be purchased in some states); once you have it, Geico won’t hike your premium for your first at-fault accident. Neither company charges for minor fender-benders under a certain dollar amount.
Telematics Programs:
Both have popular usage-based discount programs. Geico’s program is DriveEasy (app-based) and Progressive’s is Snapshot (app or plug-in device). These programs monitor your driving and can lead to discounts for safe habits. Progressive was a pioneer here and might have a slight edge in experience with telematics, but Geico’s DriveEasy is similar in function. One interesting note: a J.D. Power study on telematics found Geico’s DriveEasy program had a higher customer satisfaction rating than Progressive’s Snapshot (837 vs 816 on a 1,000-point scale). This hints that users might prefer Geico’s app experience.
Number of Discounts:
Progressive advertises having a few more total discount types than Geico – one source notes Progressive offers around 18 discounts vs. Geico’s 16 For example, Progressive has a continuous insurance discount (rewarding you for not having coverage lapses) and a small pay-in-full discount. Geico has some unique ones like a federal employee discount (Geico originally stood for Government Employees Insurance Company) and a seat belt use discount in some states. Common discounts (multi-policy, multi-car, good student, safe driver, etc.) are offered by both.
Bundling:
Both companies encourage bundling auto with other policies. Progressive can bundle with its home, renters, or even through its partners (since Progressive doesn’t underwrite home insurance itself but offers it via partners). Geico offers homeowners and renters insurance through partners as well. Typically, bundling will get you a discount of around 5-10% on each policy with either company.
Bottom Line on Coverage/Discounts: It’s mostly a tie. Both Geico and Progressive have extensive coverage options and a long list of discounts. If you’re looking for a very specific feature, that might sway you (e.g., Geico for Mechanical Breakdown coverage, or Progressive if you want a few more niche discounts). In general, you should be able to get equivalent coverage from either. It often comes down to how much discount you personally get from their usage-based programs or loyalty perks. For many, these differences aren’t deal-breakers – you’ll get solid coverage either way.
Customer Service and Satisfaction
Beyond price and coverage, it’s important to consider how each company treats its customers and handles claims:
Customer Satisfaction Scores:
According to the J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance study (which scores customer satisfaction), Geico scores slightly higher than Progressive in overall customer satisfaction. Geico scored around 818 out of 1000, compared to Progressive’s 812. This indicates Geico customers are, on average, a bit more satisfied. Both scores are above average, so neither company is bad in this regard – they’re both generally well-regarded, with Geico just a notch above.
Claims Experience:
J.D. Power also rates auto insurance claims satisfaction. Geico and Progressive tend to be in the middle of the pack. Anecdotally, Geico often gets praise for efficient claims handling and quick payouts. Progressive is known for a strong online claims process and its network of approved repair shops. Progressive does, however, have a slightly higher complaint ratio than the industry average according to NAIC data (meaning Progressive receives more complaints relative to its size). Geico’s complaint levels are typically at or below industry average. In plain terms, customers file fewer complaints about Geico.
Digital Tools and Mobile App:
Both companies excel here. Geico’s mobile app is highly rated and offers easy digital ID cards, claim filing, policy changes, etc. Progressive’s app and website are also very robust (Progressive has been a leader in online services). Geico’s virtual assistant (“Kate”) and Progressive’s chatbot are on par. It’s safe to say tech-savvy users will be fine with either, but Geico’s app has won accolades for usability in some surveys.
Agent vs Direct:
Geico operates primarily direct-to-consumer (no local agents you work with; though they do have some field offices). Progressive offers both direct and has a large independent agent network. If you prefer having a local agent you can meet or call, you might lean Progressive (by choosing a Progressive policy through an independent broker). Geico is typically handled via phone or online with Geico’s own representatives. Both provide 24/7 customer support.
Financial Strength:
Both are financially strong. Geico is a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway, and Progressive is a Fortune 500 company – neither is going to have issues paying claims. They each have A+ or higher financial ratings.
Bottom Line on Service: Geico has a slight edge in customer satisfaction metrics and tends to generate fewer complaints. Many customers rave about Geico’s ease of use and claims speed. Progressive also has solid service, but with marginally lower scores and a higher complaint index in recent data. If customer experience is your priority and you want the statistically “safer” bet for happy service, Geico might be the better choice. That said, many people have had great experiences with Progressive as well – both are among the largest insurers for a reason.
Which Should You Choose – Geico or Progressive?
Ultimately, the “better” insurer depends on your personal needs and situation:
Choose Geico if:
You prioritize the lowest price and have a clean record (Geico is likely to give you the cheaper quote in this case), you want slightly higher-rated customer service, or you’re interested in Mechanical Breakdown Insurance for your vehicle. Geico is also a great choice if you’re comfortable handling your insurance fully online or via their app.
Choose Progressive if:
You have any marks on your driving record or other factors (like poor credit) that might make you a higher risk – Progressive might offer you a more favorable rate in those cases. Also, if you value working with an independent agent or you’re bundling multiple types of insurance (Progressive can be a one-stop shop through its partners), Progressive could edge out Geico. Progressive’s array of discounts (like for continuous insurance, homeowner, etc.) might benefit certain individuals more than Geico’s structure.
Consider both (and compare):
Because pricing is so situation-dependent, it’s wise to get quotes from both Geico and Progressive and compare. Many drivers who do this find one is much cheaper than the other for them. If, for example, Geico comes in $300/year less for the same coverage, that likely tilts the scales in Geico’s favor – and vice versa. Both companies allow quick online quotes, so it’s easy to see who’s giving you the better deal.
For many shoppers, the decision might be tough because the companies are comparable in reliability and offerings. Some even choose based on intangible preferences – e.g., you might just like Geico’s gecko ads or Progressive’s Flo and feel a familiarity with one brand. That’s fine, but be sure it aligns with the practical factors of price and service.
One more thing to keep in mind: you can switch insurers relatively easily. If you choose one and later decide the other is better, you’re not locked in forever. The insurance market is competitive, and both Geico and Progressive have easy cancellation policies if you give notice. So, you could even try one for 6 months and see how you like it, then adjust next renewal if needed.
FAQs: Geico vs. Progressive
Is Geico really cheaper than Progressive?
In a lot of cases, yes – Geico tends to be cheaper for many drivers, especially those with clean records. Studies have shown Geico’s rates beating Progressive’s in the majority of states. As an example, one analysis found Geico’s liability quote averaging around $55 vs Progressive’s $101. However, there are scenarios where Progressive can be cheaper (like for drivers with an accident/DUI or certain states). Always compare your own quotes; you might be among the exceptions.
Do Geico and Progressive offer the same types of discounts?
There’s a lot of overlap. Both offer multi-policy (bundling), multi-vehicle, safe driver, good student, and homeowner (Progressive) or legacy customer (Geico) discounts. Progressive has a few more niche discounts (continuous insurance, teen driver training, etc.), totaling around 18 kinds to Geico’s 16. Geico has a unique affiliation discount for federal employees and some alumni/association groups. But in general, neither is missing any major common discount, and both have usage-based discounts (DriveEasy vs Snapshot). It’s worth asking each for a list of discounts you qualify for – you might discover one has something the other doesn’t in your case.
Which company has better customer service and claims handling – Geico or Progressive?
Both are reputable, but Geico edges out Progressive slightly in customer satisfaction surveys. Geico tends to receive slightly fewer complaints and slightly higher satisfaction ratings. Many customers praise Geico for friendly service and fast claims resolution. Progressive also generally provides good service and has innovative claims tools (like the Name Your Price tool and a robust online claims tracker). You likely will get decent service with either, but if we go by the numbers, Geico has a minor advantage in overall customer happiness.
I’m a high-risk driver (DUI, accident, etc.). Which is better for me?
Progressive often is the better bet for high-risk drivers. Progressive has a history of insuring a broader range of driver profiles and may give comparatively less severe surcharges for issues like DUI. For example, Progressive is known to sometimes offer lower rates than Geico if you have a recent accident or violation. Geico, while cheap for clean drivers, can become pricey with infractions. Also, Progressive has an entire division (Progressive’s subsidiary companies) that focus on non-standard (high-risk) auto insurance. That said, it’s still wise to get quotes from multiple companies that specialize in high-risk policies to see the best rate.
Can I use both Geico and Progressive at the same time (for different policies)?
Yes, you could. For instance, some people might have auto insurance with Geico and maybe a motorcycle or RV insurance with Progressive. There’s no rule against using different insurers for different policies. However, you would miss out on any multi-policy discount. Both Geico and Progressive offer multi-policy discounts if you bundle auto with other coverage. So generally, it’s simpler and often cheaper to stick with one company for multiple policies. But if, say, Geico doesn’t insure a specific item you have (like a boat) and Progressive does, you might split it that way.
Final Thoughts
Geico vs. Progressive is a matchup of two insurance giants with more similarities than differences. Geico often wins on price for the majority, and boasts slightly higher customer satisfaction, making it a favorable choice for many drivers seeking a straightforward, low-cost policy. Progressive distinguishes itself with flexibility – being friendlier to those with imperfect records and offering a few more bells and whistles (like the Name Your Price tool and a larger menu of discounts). The best way to decide is to get quotes from both and see which one offers you the better combination of cost and coverage. Whichever you choose, rest assured you’ll be in the hands of a top insurer. And remember, you’re not locked in – you can revisit this comparison whenever your policy comes up for renewal to make sure you’re still with the provider that’s best for you. In the end, the “winner” is whichever company saves you money and gives you peace of mind on the road.
Supercharge Your Credit Cards
Experience smarter spending with Kudos and unlock more from your credit cards. Earn $20.00 when you sign up for Kudos with "GET20" and make an eligible Kudos Boost purchase.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
