Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
How Much Umbrella Insurance Do I Need & How Much Does It Cost? (2025)
December 12, 2024
So you’re convinced that umbrella insurance is a smart safety net – now the next questions are: How much coverage should you get? and What will it cost? Getting the right amount is important; you want enough to truly protect your assets without buying more than necessary.
And understanding the cost will help you budget for this extra policy (spoiler: it’s probably less than you think). In this guide, we’ll walk through how to figure out the umbrella coverage limit that suits your situation and break down the typical costs for umbrella insurance in 2025. We’ll also discuss what factors affect the price and how you might save on premiums.
By the end, you should know whether you’re good with a $1 million umbrella, or if you might need $2 million or more, and you’ll have a clear idea of what that level of coverage will roughly cost you per year. Let’s secure that peace of mind without breaking the bank!
Determining How Much Umbrella Coverage You Need
The general principle for deciding on an umbrella insurance limit is to cover at least all your assets (current and sometimes future). In practice, consider these steps:
1. Calculate Your Net Worth
Add up the value of your assets – your home equity, bank accounts, investments, cars, etc. Let’s say, for example, your assets total $800,000. This is roughly the amount you stand to lose in a worst-case lawsuit. Many advisors say your umbrella coverage should be at least equal to your net worth.
In this example, you’d look at a $1 million umbrella policy (since they come in million increments, you’d round up a bit from $800k). The idea is that if you were sued, the policy could cover up to that amount, preserving what you own.
2. Consider Future Income and Lifestyle
Sometimes, lawsuits can seek not just what you have now, but also future earnings (especially if you have a high salary). If you have a high income or expect significantly higher net worth later, you might want to pad your umbrella limit above your current net worth.
Umbrella policies can shield future earnings by providing funds for settlements instead of your wages being garnished. So in such cases, you might get a bit more than just current assets – maybe 1–2 million to also cover where you’re headed financially.
3. Review Common Liability Awards
While it’s hard to predict lawsuit amounts, you can consider some benchmarks. If you own a home and drive, claims in those realms can sometimes exceed $1M, but it’s relatively rare to see something like $5M unless extreme. If your net worth is, say, $300k, a $1M umbrella is usually plenty. If your net worth is $2M, you might opt for a $2M umbrella.
Generally, umbrella policies of $1M or $2M cover the vast majority of situations for average families. Higher limits like $5M or $10M are usually carried by those with very high assets or unique exposures (or they just want belt-and-suspenders security).
4. Mind the Umbrella Increments
Remember, insurers sell umbrella insurance in increments of $1 million. You can’t usually buy $500k or $1.5M – it will be 1, 2, 3 million, etc. So even if your calculated need is $600k, you’ll be getting $1M as the minimum. Similarly, if you think you need around $1.5M, you’ll have to choose between $1M or $2M; in that case, it’s safer to round up to $2M to avoid being underinsured. It’s better to have a little extra cushion than not enough.
5. Check Underlying Policy Requirements
Sometimes the amount of umbrella you can get is influenced by the underlying coverage you carry. For example, an insurer might say “to get a $5M umbrella, you need higher base auto limits (like $500k) than for a $1M umbrella”. Ensure you meet those requirements; this is more a technicality, but if you’re aiming for a higher umbrella limit, verify if you need to adjust your auto/home liability limits accordingly.
In many cases, $1 million is the default recommendation because it covers a broad range of scenarios and for most people with moderate assets, that fully protects them. If you have more assets or risks, $2 million or $3 million could be considered.
Evaluate what you’re protecting: for instance, if you own a $1.5M house outright and have $1M in investments, a $2–3M umbrella would ensure that even a catastrophic claim won’t force the sale of your home or dipping into those investments.
Umbrella Insurance Coverage Options
All umbrella policies provide liability coverage, but the way you can customize or what options you have mostly revolve around the limit. There aren’t a lot of “bells and whistles” – umbrella is fairly straightforward. However, consider:
- Personal vs. Commercial Umbrella: Make sure you’re getting a personal umbrella policy for personal liability. If you also run a business, know that personal umbrella won’t cover business-related liabilities. There are commercial umbrella policies for businesses. Keep them separate as needed.
- Stacking/Combining Limits: If $5M+ coverage is needed, some insurers will have you get multiple policies or go to specialty insurers. Most standard insurers offer up to $5 million personal umbrella. If you need more (say $10M), you might get an excess policy from a specialty market. This won’t apply to most individuals, but worth noting if you’re in ultra-high-net-worth territory.
- Retention (Deductible) Options: Typically, personal umbrellas don’t have a deductible if your underlying insurance covers the claim. If the umbrella covers something not covered by underlying (e.g. libel), some policies have a small “self-insured retention” (like $250 or $500) you pay – essentially a deductible for claims where no base policy applies. This is standard and not usually something you choose; it’s built in.
- Defense Costs Outside vs Inside Limits: Most personal umbrella policies pay defense costs outside the liability limit (meaning legal fees don’t erode your $1M coverage). Some rare policies might count defense costs inside limits (so the $1M includes legal fees), but that’s not common for personal lines – more a commercial policy thing.
- Excess Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage: In some states/with some insurers, you can add an endorsement so that the umbrella also boosts your uninsured motorist coverage (to protect you if an at-fault driver injures you and they have no insurance). This doesn’t involve liability you owe, but rather what you can claim. Not every insurer offers it; if you’re interested in extra protection for yourself in auto accidents, ask about this option.
Those considerations aside, your main “option” with umbrella is choosing the coverage limit that fits your needs. Focus on that; pick a number that covers your assets and risk comfort.
Quick Rule of Thumb: Umbrella limit ≈ Your total assets (round up to nearest $1M). If you have significant risk factors (like multiple teen drivers, multiple rentals, etc.), maybe add an extra $1M on top of that for peace of mind.
How Much Does Umbrella Insurance Cost in 2025?
The cost of umbrella insurance is one of its selling points – it’s usually very affordable for the amount of coverage you get. Let’s break down the typical costs and what influences them:
Average Cost for $1 Million Coverage
On average, a $1 million personal umbrella policy costs about $150 to $300 per year. Many sources, including independent insurance surveys, put the average around $200–$250. Progressive Insurance noted an average of $383/year for $1M in one example for a certain profile, but that tends to be on the higher end (that figure might include a scenario with two cars and two drivers). Generally, if you have a clean record and just one home and two cars, you might find your premium around $200/year for $1M coverage.
Cost per Additional $1 Million
If you want more than $1M, the cost increases incrementally but not linearly. Typically, the second million costs less than the first, the third even less, and so on. A rule of thumb: each additional $1M might cost around $50–$75 extra per year. This is why some people opt for $2M even if $1M might suffice – the additional cost could be only a few dollars a month more.
Factors Affecting the Premium
- Number of Properties and Vehicles: Every home, rental property, car, boat, etc., that the umbrella covers can add to the cost. The insurer views each as a source of liability risk.
- Drivers in Household: More drivers (especially young ones) = higher risk. If you have teen drivers, expect an uptick in cost. One 17-year-old driver might increase your umbrella premium by a noticeable amount, because statistically they significantly raise the chance of an auto claim.
- Your location: Rates can vary by state or region. Umbrella insurance in litigious states (like perhaps California, Florida, New York) might cost more than in states with fewer large lawsuits. Also, if you live in a major city vs a rural area, there could be slight differences.
- Your history (claims/records): If you have prior liability claims or a DUI on record, for example, an insurer might charge more or even decline umbrella coverage. A clean driving record and no liability lawsuits in your past helps keep the premium low.
- Credit Score (insurance score): In many states, insurers use an insurance credit score to set rates. A better score can mean a lower premium, although umbrella is already cheap so the difference might not be very big here as it could be for auto insurance.
- Coverage amount: Obviously, $5M will cost more than $1M. As discussed, though, the increment is smaller for higher amounts after the first. If you double your coverage from $1M to $2M, you might see something like a 30-40% increase in premium, not 100% increase.
- Multi-policy discount: If you have your umbrella with the same insurer as your home/auto, they often give a discount. Sometimes the umbrella itself is cheaper (because they know your whole profile), or they give a discount on the home/auto and effectively bundle the savings.
Insurance costs have been rising in some areas (auto and home insurance saw increases due to various factors like inflation in medical/legal costs). Umbrella premiums might creep up slightly too, but given their starting low base, even a 5-10% increase still keeps them quite affordable.
Always get a current quote, but don’t be surprised if the price is similar to what it was a few years ago – umbrella rates tend to be relatively stable because the frequency of claims is low (even if severity can be high).
Tips to Get the Best Umbrella Insurance Rates
While umbrella insurance is inexpensive, who doesn’t like to save money? Here are a few tips:
1. Bundle with the Same Insurer
Easiest way – if you place your umbrella policy with the same company that has your auto and home, you’ll usually get the best rate. Many insurers only offer umbrella to their existing auto/home customers. Bundling not only might knock a few dollars off, but it avoids any gaps or disputes between insurers in a claim. It simplifies things. Ask your current insurer for a quote first; if you have a good record, it should be competitive.
2. Compare if Needed
If your current insurer’s umbrella quote seems high (or if they don’t offer umbrella), shop around. Some companies (or independent agents) can offer a stand-alone umbrella policy that sits over other insurers’ policies. If switching all your policies to one insurer yields a better overall deal, consider that as well – just ensure that new insurer’s auto/home rates are good too.
3. Maintain a Good Driving Record
Since auto accidents are a major source of umbrella claims, your driving history impacts your rate. Avoiding DUIs, serious tickets, or at-fault accidents will keep your umbrella (and auto) premiums low. If you have incidents, over time (3-5 years) as they fall off, your rates should improve.
4. Ask about Discounts
Some insurers might have little-known discounts for umbrella policies. For instance, if you haven’t had any claims in a long time, or if you have certain safety features (maybe a home security system might slightly reduce liability risk and could be considered). There’s no harm in asking “Are there any discounts applicable to my umbrella policy?” The agent might double-check if multi-policy or loyalty discounts are in place.
5. Increase Underlying Deductibles
Indirectly, one way to save on umbrella is to save on your other policies and put those savings toward it. Umbrella premiums themselves won’t change if you raise your auto deductible, for example, but your overall insurance budget will. If you’re adding an umbrella and concerned about total cost, you could consider raising your auto or home insurance deductibles (if you can comfortably absorb a bit more out-of-pocket in small claims) to reduce those premiums.
6. Review and Update Regularly
Every couple of years, re-evaluate your umbrella coverage and shop again if necessary. Your profile might change (kids grow up – which can lower rate once they’re out of the house or older; you might sell a boat or pay off a house, etc.). Update your insurer so they price it accurately. If you sold a rental property and didn’t tell your insurer, they might still be charging for it under the umbrella. Keep things current to avoid overpaying.
On the flip side, don’t skimp on coverage amount to save a very small amount. For example, if $2M coverage costs only $50 more than $1M, it’s likely worth the extra $50 for the added protection if you were on the fence about needing that second million. The incremental cost is usually low, so base your coverage decision on need, not just cost.
Bringing It All Together: Coverage vs. Cost
Let’s combine the two major questions:
If you have, say, $600k in assets, two cars, and one home – you likely need about a $1 million umbrella. It might cost around $200 a year. That $200 buys you an extra $1,000,000 in coverage above your existing policies, covering many scenarios and including legal defense. That’s tremendous value for the price.
If you have $1.5 million in assets, a vacation condo, a boat, and a teenage driver – you might consider a $2 million umbrella (to fully cover assets and higher risk). That might cost around $300-$450 a year given the extra exposures. Still, under $40 a month for $2,000,000 in coverage is a great deal for the peace of mind it provides.
In any scenario, compare that premium to what a single hour of an attorney’s time costs (could be $200-$300/hr for a decent attorney). Umbrella insurance essentially pre-pays for a whole legal team to defend you if needed, plus covers settlements.
A quick reality check: Umbrella policies do pay out for real people. They’re not unicorns. While you personally may never have a claim, thousands of umbrella claims happen each year – from tragic car accidents to dog bites to freak injuries. The policy exists because those events, while statistically infrequent, do occur. So think of the premium as “stress-free living” cost. For a few hundred bucks, you remove the worry of “what if this rare disaster strikes me.”
Finally, when budgeting the cost, consider using tools or strategies to offset it. For example, some credit cards offer rewards or cashback on insurance bills – use them (Kudos can help pick which card, as mentioned). Or consider the umbrella premium as part of your overall financial wellness spending – maybe cutting one dinner out a year covers it. It often helps to put it in perspective: $200 a year is about $17 a month – which is maybe 3-4 fancy coffees. Many find that sacrificing a couple of coffees for millions in coverage is totally worth it!
Conclusion
By assessing how much coverage you need and understanding the costs, you’re now equipped to make a smart decision about umbrella insurance. In 2025, it remains an affordable way to protect a lifetime’s worth of assets and future earnings.
Determine the coverage that fits your life, get quotes to see the cost, and you’ll likely find that the peace of mind far outweighs the premium. And as always, as you protect what you have, don’t forget to make the most of what you have – whether that’s maximizing credit card rewards with tools like Kudos or investing wisely – so you continue to grow your wealth under the safe “umbrella” you’ve put in place.
FAQ: Umbrella Coverage Amounts & Costs
Is a $1 million umbrella policy enough for me?
For many people, $1 million is sufficient, as it covers beyond what most standard policies do and many potential claims won’t exceed that figure. If your net worth is under $1M and you don’t have unusually high liability risks, $1M is a great starting point.
What does a $5 million umbrella policy cost?
Rough ballpark, a $5 million personal umbrella might cost around $400–$600 per year for an average risk profile. The first $1M could be $200, and each additional million maybe $50-75. So perhaps $200 + (4 x $50) = $400 on the low end, or $250 + (4 x $75) = $550 on a higher end example. If you have youthful drivers or multiple properties, it might push closer to $600-800. It varies by insurer. But even at $600/year, $5M coverage is only $50/month – still a solid value for that high net worth individual or someone who wants extra protection.
Do umbrella premiums increase a lot after a claim or as the years go on?
Umbrella premiums generally stay relatively stable year to year if your profile doesn’t change. They’re less volatile than auto insurance rates, for example. If you have an umbrella claim, it could impact your premium – especially if the claim was due to something like a serious at-fault incident (which might also affect your auto/home rates). Some insurers might non-renew you after a very large claim, or continue coverage but at a higher rate.
Can I get umbrella insurance if I don’t own a car or home (and thus have no underlying policies)?
It’s tricky. Most insurers require you to have underlying auto or property insurance to attach an umbrella. If you truly have no car and you rent without a renters policy, an insurer doesn’t have a base to extend from.
Double the Cash, Zero the Worry
Looking for consistent rewards without the hassle? The Citi Double Cash® Card rewards you twice: 1% when you buy, another 1% when you pay—for a total 2% cash back on every purchase with no categories to track. Plus, smart balance transfer options help you take control of existing debt. Simple, powerful, perfect for today's savvy spenders.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
