Kudos has partnered with CardRatings and Red Ventures for our coverage of credit card products. Kudos, CardRatings, and Red Ventures may receive a commission from card issuers. Kudos may receive commission from card issuers. Some of the card offers that appear on Kudos are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. Kudos tries to include as many card companies and offers as we are aware of, including offers from issuers that don't pay us, but we may not cover all card companies or all available card offers. You don't have to use our links, but we're grateful when you do!
How to Compare Car Insurance Quotes (Step-by-Step Guide)
February 6, 2025
Shopping for car insurance can feel overwhelming, but it’s one of the most effective ways to save money. In fact, experts agree that comparing quotes is the #1 tip to get the cheapest car insurance rates. If you’re not sure where to start, don’t worry – this guide will walk you through exactly how to compare car insurance quotes and find the best deal. By following these simple steps, you can quickly identify which insurer offers the coverage you need at the lowest price. Let’s dive in!
Why Comparing Car Insurance Quotes Is Important
No two insurance companies will quote you the same price. Each uses its own formula to evaluate your risk, so premiums can vary by hundreds of dollars for the exact same driver. For example, one major study found that the cheapest insurer for a given person could change after an accident – you might have to switch companies to keep the lowest rate. The only way to know you’re getting a good deal is to compare quotes from multiple insurers. By doing so, you ensure you’re not overpaying and you can potentially save a lot (often, drivers save a few hundred per year just by switching to a better quote).
How to Compare Car Insurance Quotes: Step-by-Step
Following these steps will help you gather and evaluate car insurance quotes efficiently:
1. Gather Your Personal and Vehicle Information:
Before obtaining quotes, compile all the necessary info. You’ll typically need:
- Driver information: Name, date of birth, address, occupation, marital status, driver’s license number, and driving history for each driver in the household. Have details of any accidents or tickets from the past 3-5 years handy.
- Vehicle information: Year, make, and model of each car, the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN), current mileage, and how the car is used (commute distance, annual mileage).
- Current policy details (if any): Note your current coverage levels and limits, and your current premium. This gives a baseline for comparison.
Having this information ready will make filling out quote forms much quicker.
2. Decide on the Coverage You Need
Determine what coverage levels you want before comparing. This includes liability limits (e.g. 100/300/50 for bodily injury/property damage), and whether you need additional coverages like collision, comprehensive, uninsured motorist, or personal injury protection. Also choose a deductible for collision/comprehensive (common choices are $500 or $1,000). By setting a desired coverage package upfront, you can ensure each quote you get is for equivalent coverage. This way, you’re comparing prices for the same level of protection. (Tip:) If you’re not sure, you can use your current coverage as a starting point or consult state minimum requirements and then consider higher limits for better protection.
3. Use an Online Comparison Tool or Work with an Agent
Now it’s time to actually get quotes. You have a few options:
- Use an online comparison platform: Online tools (like the one integrated with the Kudos blog) allow you to enter your information once and receive quotes from multiple insurance companies at the same time. This is a huge time-saver. Kudos simplifies comparing auto insurance rates, quickly finding the best rate tailored for you. It’s easy and completely free. By entering your info on Kudos, for example, you can instantly see quotes from a range of insurers side by side.
- Go directly to insurer websites: Alternatively, you can visit each insurance company’s website and fill out their quote form individually. This is more time-consuming, but it lets you include some insurers that might not show up on comparison sites.
- Call an independent agent or broker: An independent insurance agent can collect quotes from multiple companies for you, provide advice on coverage, and sometimes get special rates. This personal touch can be helpful if you prefer guidance.
Whichever method you choose, aim to gather at least 3-5 quotes from reputable insurers. This number of quotes will give you a good range of prices to compare; NerdWallet’s research shows that shopping around widely can yield the biggest savings.
4. Provide Consistent Details for Each Quote
Ensure that you input the same information and choose the same coverage levels for each quote. This means the liability limits, deductibles, and extras (like roadside assistance or rental car coverage) should be kept consistent when getting quotes from different companies. The goal is an apples-to-apples comparison. If one quote is assuming $50,000 bodily injury coverage and another is for $100,000, the prices will differ because of coverage, not because one insurer is cheaper. So double-check the coverage selections as you go. Consistency will let you accurately identify which insurer truly offers the best price for your chosen coverage.
5. Compare the Quotes Side by Side
Once you have multiple quotes, it’s time to compare them:
- Price: Look at the total six-month or annual premium for each policy. Identify which companies are offering the lowest rates and which are more expensive. You might find, for example, that Geico’s quote is $200 cheaper per year than the next option, or perhaps Progressive and Allstate are within $50 of each other.
- Coverage details: Ensure each quote includes all the coverages you requested. Check for differences like one quote including roadside assistance or accident forgiveness automatically. Minor differences can affect price.
- Discounts applied: Quotes often show which discounts have been factored in (e.g., multi-car, safe driver, etc.). Take note, especially if one quote is higher – it might be missing a discount you qualify for. You can often ask the insurer or adjust the quote online to add relevant discounts.
- Payment options: Sometimes, paying in full or by EFT (auto-pay) can make one quote effectively cheaper due to discounts for those payment methods. Consider these if shown.
Creating a small comparison table or list for yourself to line up the offerings may also be helpful.
6. Consider Company Reputation and Reviews
Price is important, but it’s not everything. Once you identify the lowest quotes, do a quick quality check on those insurers:
- Customer service: Research customer satisfaction – for instance, check J.D. Power rankings or online reviews. (A quick find: Geico’s customer satisfaction score is slightly above Progressive’s, but both are reputable.)
- Claims handling: Look for indicators of how well the company handles claims. You want an insurer that will be responsive if you have an accident.
- Financial strength: Ensure the company is financially stable (A.M. Best, Moody’s, or Standard & Poor’s ratings can tell you this), so you know they can pay claims.
- Coverage features: Note if any insurer offers better add-ons or perks. For example, one might include accident forgiveness or a disappearing deductible, which adds value.
If the cheapest company has poor reviews or lacks a coverage you want, you might lean toward the second-cheapest that offers more reliability. Often, the top few quotes are from well-known insurers, so you’ll just be weighing small differences.
7. Choose the Best Quote and Finalize the Policy
After weighing price and quality, pick the quote that offers the best overall value. Contact that insurer (or click through on the comparison tool) to purchase the policy. While buying, double-check all details you provided (vehicle VINs, driver info) for accuracy, and ensure the coverage levels are as desired. Once you purchase, the new insurer will typically help cancel your old policy (if switching mid-term) or will schedule the new policy to start when your current one expires. Be careful to avoid any lapse in coverage when switching.
Finally, set your new policy to renew or mark your calendar to compare again at your next renewal. It’s smart to repeat this quote comparison process every year or two, as insurance rates can change and a different insurer might become cheapest for you over time.
Tips and Tricks for Easier Quote Comparison
Save quotes with reference numbers:
If you get quotes on multiple websites, save the quote reference or confirmation email. This makes it easier to retrieve or adjust the quote later, rather than re-entering data.
Use the same coverage start date:
When quoting, use a consistent desired start date. Closer start dates can sometimes yield slightly different prices.
Mind hard vs. soft credit inquiries:
Most insurance quotes use a soft credit check (no impact to your score). It’s safe to get multiple quotes. If any insurer needs a hard inquiry (rare for quotes), they will typically ask permission.
Bundle for more savings:
While comparing auto insurance, consider if you need other policies. Many insurers give a discount if you bundle auto with renters or homeowners insurance. Comparing bundle quotes could save additional money.
Leverage quote-match offers:
Some companies have programs where they match a competitor’s quote or offer a discount because you found a cheaper price elsewhere. It never hurts to call an insurer and politely ask, “I like your company, but I got a lower quote from X – is there any discount you can apply to match it?” The worst they can say is no, and you’ll take the cheapest quote you have.
FAQs: Comparing Car Insurance Quotes
How often should I compare car insurance quotes?
It’s a good idea to compare quotes at least once a year, or at minimum at every policy renewal (typically every 6 or 12 months). Insurance rates change frequently, and your own circumstances (age, credit score, new discounts) can change too. By checking yearly, you ensure you’re still getting a good deal. You should also compare quotes after any major life change (buying a new car, moving, getting married, etc.), or after any accidents or tickets fall off your record.
Does getting multiple insurance quotes hurt my credit score?
No – requesting car insurance quotes will not hurt your credit score. Insurers do often check your credit-based insurance score when quoting, but it’s a soft inquiry, which does not affect your credit. It’s similar to when you check your own credit. Even if you get 10 quotes, these soft pulls won’t impact your score. (Note: actually purchasing a policy typically doesn’t involve a hard pull either, unlike some loans or credit cards.)
Should I go with the lowest quote, or are there other factors to consider?
While the price is crucial, you should also consider the insurer’s reputation and whether the coverage is exactly what you need. If the lowest quote comes from a company you’ve never heard of, do a quick background check on their customer service and claims satisfaction. If it checks out, great. Also, make sure that cheapest quote isn’t missing something important – for example, perhaps it excluded collision coverage to appear cheaper. As long as you’re comparing equal coverage and the insurer is reputable, going with the lowest quote is the smart move.
Can I compare insurance quotes without entering a lot of personal information?
To get accurate quotes, you will need to provide details like your address, vehicle info, and driving history. Be cautious of any site claiming to give quotes with just a zip code – those won’t be accurate until full info is provided. That said, many comparison sites streamline the process by asking for your info once and getting multiple quotes. It takes a bit of effort, but you can often complete the task in 10-15 minutes. Providing accurate info is important; if you leave something out (like an accident) your quote won’t match your final price.
Is it better to use an agent or go online for comparing quotes?
It depends on your preference. Online comparison tools are faster and let you see many quotes instantly – great for the tech-savvy and those comfortable making decisions solo. An independent agent, on the other hand, can give personalized advice and handle the quote gathering for you. They might have insight into which company is best for your specific needs. Both methods can yield good results. Some people like to do an online comparison first to gather baseline quotes, then talk to an agent to see if they can beat those or provide more context.
Final Thoughts
Comparing car insurance quotes is the surest way to save money and get the best insurance deal. It may take a little time, but the payoff can be huge – you might find a policy that offers the same coverage for hundreds less. Use the step-by-step approach outlined above to simplify the process. Remember, insurance is not a one-and-done purchase; regular checkups on your rate can keep your costs optimized. With the help of tools like Kudos or independent agents, quote comparison is easier than ever. Make it a habit to shop around, and you’ll feel confident you’re never paying more than you need to for auto insurance coverage.
Supercharge Your Credit Cards
Experience smarter spending with Kudos and unlock more from your credit cards. Earn $20.00 when you sign up for Kudos with "GET20" and make an eligible Kudos Boost purchase.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions expressed here are those of Kudos alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
